An independent Indian distributor may suit a US company testing demand or seeking local sales coverage through established channels. An Indian subsidiary may suit a company that needs direct customer contracts, local employees, or closer control over inventory and after-sales service. The right choice depends on the product category, the activities each party will carry out, and the economics at realistic sales volumes. Before committing, identify who must import the goods, who will invoice customers, and who can deliver the service customers expect.
Who Does What Under Each Model?
Follow one order from the US supplier to the Indian buyer, including who owns the goods, issues the invoice, and handles claims.
How a Local Distributor Makes the Sale?
In a typical buy-resell arrangement, the US supplier invoices the distributor, which buys the goods and takes title at the point specified in the contract. From there, the distributor usually clears the import in its own name, holds inventory, invoices Indian customers, and collects their payments. It hires local staff and manages customer relationships. In addition, the agreement can require the distributor to handle warranty claims locally and let it recover agreed repair or replacement costs from the supplier.
By comparison, an agent typically solicits or negotiates orders on the US company’s behalf. The principal may remain the seller and invoice the buyer directly, while the agent earns a commission. Consequently, the contract must identify who can accept orders and who takes responsibility for importing the goods.
How an Indian Subsidiary Makes the Sale?
An Indian private limited subsidiary can buy the product from its US parent, take title under their supply agreement, and clear the goods as importer of record. It then invoices the Indian customer, collects payment and handles any warranty claims it has agreed to cover. As a separate legal entity, the subsidiary can employ local sales and service staff and contract with logistics or repair providers.
The parent and subsidiary should document who sets credit terms, approves stock purchases, and pays for defects attributable to manufacturing. For example, the Indian entity can manage customer returns while the parent supplies replacement parts under a separate arrangement. Align those agreements with the local team’s commitments to customers.
Which Activities Fit the Proposed Legal Route?
List the activities the Indian business will carry out before choosing a structure. For instance, importing goods for wholesale, selling directly to consumers, and operating an online marketplace raise different questions under India’s foreign investment rules.
Foreign Investment and Incorporation for a Subsidiary
Check whether India permits foreign direct investment in the activity, what ownership cap or operating conditions apply, and whether the investment qualifies for the automatic route or needs prior government approval. Also review the investor’s ownership chain, where beneficial ownership rules could affect that route. In addition, check the specific retail and online sales rules before assuming that a subsidiary set up for wholesale can open a consumer webstore. India generally restricts foreign investment in inventory-based e-commerce for domestic consumer sales. If a specific retail route permits online sales, check the conditions before relying on it.
Before setting up a local operation, check which legal route applies. Incorporating an Indian subsidiary creates a separate Indian company. Separately, check whether foreign company registration in India applies if the US entity itself establishes a place of business and conducts business in India. In that case, check whether foreign exchange rules also require permission.
Once you confirm the entry route, plan for the registered office, directors, and parent company documents. Then coordinate capital funding and applicable foreign investment reporting with the authorised dealer bank. During operations, budget for accounting, statutory audit, corporate and tax filings, and any payroll and employment obligations that its local staffing arrangements trigger.
Import and Product Checks for a Distributor
Ask the distributor to show its Importer Exporter Code, relevant registrations, and product approvals before the first shipment. Next, confirm the tariff classification and check for import restrictions. Depending on the goods, verify whether Indian rules require product certification, a sector licence, testing or specific packaging declarations. Where declarations apply, assign responsibility for preparing labels and checking the finished pack before dispatch or sale, as applicable.
Also identify who holds each approval and what it covers. An approval may attach to an importer, manufacturer, factory or product model, depending on the regime. Therefore, check whether a different importer can rely on it or must obtain an amendment or fresh approval before taking over new shipments.
Landed Cost, Cash Flow and Tax Exposure
Build both forecasts around the same product, shipment size, and customer price. That way, it is easier to compare the profit each model produces and the cash each one needs before customers pay.
Commercial Costs and Working Capital
Start with the supplier price, freight, insurance, customs duties, and clearance charges. Next, add inland transport, warehousing, local delivery, returns and warranty costs to estimate the cost of serving the customer. Then show recoverable import taxes separately. Where the importer qualifies for input tax credit, integrated goods and services tax paid at import may still absorb cash until the business can use the credit.
With distribution, model the price the distributor will pay and the margin it needs to fund stock, extend credit and provide service. Check whether it expects the supplier to pay for promotions, slow stock or warranty replacements. With a subsidiary, include office costs, payroll, professional fees, and financing for inventory and receivables. Higher volume can spread fixed costs across more units. However, longer customer credit or frequent returns can increase the cash the subsidiary needs even as sales grow. To test your assumptions, run a lower volume forecast and a delayed payment forecast. If the distributor pays the supplier before collecting from its own customers, distinguish the supplier’s receivable from the distributor’s customer receivables. Include the cost of any credit the supplier still extends.
GST, Customs Valuation and Income Tax
Map goods and services tax (GST) registration, invoicing and input tax credit to the actual flow of goods and services. For example, check whose details appear on the bill of entry and whether that party can use the import credit. Also review customs valuation where the parent sells to its subsidiary or charges royalties that may affect the customs value. Customs and income tax apply different valuation tests, so document how the business supports each figure.
Cross-border goods purchases, royalties, and service fees between the parent and subsidiary can raise transfer pricing questions. Identify which entity performs the work, uses assets, and bears risks, then document arm’s length pricing and check the applicable reporting requirements.
For the US company’s tax exposure, review Indian law and the tax treaty between India and the US if the company qualifies for treaty benefits. In particular, examine whether it does business through local premises, sends personnel to perform services, or gives an Indian party authority that it habitually exercises to conclude contracts for the US company. The treaty also addresses certain delivery arrangements and cases where a person habitually secures orders wholly or almost wholly for the foreign enterprise. In either model, compare the contract with what local staff and partners actually do. For installation projects, record who supervises the site and how long the work lasts.
Customer Control and Contract Protections
A subsidiary gives the US group a local counterparty for buyers that require an Indian contract and lets the group manage local pricing, sales records and service standards directly. Before relying on this advantage, confirm each buyer’s eligibility criteria. For example, a tender may require the bidder to meet turnover or service experience criteria in addition to having an Indian entity.
Under distribution, the local partner brings its customer network and generally manages resale pricing and account relationships. Set out what the supplier needs to protect the brand and monitor performance in the distribution agreement.
- Define the territory and permitted channels, including online outlets and any accounts the supplier reserves.
- Set the scope and duration of exclusivity, sales targets and inventory commitments.
- Allocate warranty administration, replacement costs, spare parts and service response times.
- Specify the customer and sales information the distributor can share lawfully and how it may use trademarks.
- Set termination rights, notice periods and the procedure for stock and open orders at exit.
For example, exclusivity tied to measurable sales targets gives the supplier a basis to revisit coverage if demand outpaces the distributor’s reach. Likewise, monthly reporting on sales volumes and returns helps the supplier plan stock without assuming it can access every customer record. Check Indian competition rules before introducing resale price restrictions or restrictions on competing products. Review how those terms would operate in practice, including any incentives or penalties tied to pricing.
When to Start With a Distributor
A distributor can help test whether Indian buyers will reorder at a price that covers the costs of supply and service. To make the pilot measurable, give it a defined territory, review date, and a few concrete measures, such as repeat orders, customer payment performance, and warranty claims. Then use the results to decide whether sales justify a staffed local operation.
- Suppose a US supplier sells standard warehouse accessories through established dealers. If a distributor already serves those buyers and can hold stock, the supplier can test demand in a limited territory and review replenishment orders by dealer.
- Now suppose a US supplier sells equipment that requires installation and periodic servicing. If buyers expect direct contracts and guaranteed response times, a subsidiary may suit the sale. First verify the investment route and the cost of staffing the local service operation.
If you may switch models, plan the handover while negotiating the agreement. Exclusivity may prevent the subsidiary from selling into the same territory before the agreement ends. Meanwhile, customer contracts may require consent to transfer, and buyers may need to approve the new vendor. Agree on who will sell or repurchase remaining stock and handle existing orders, claims, and warranties. Before switching, check product approvals, labels and importer details. Where customers need uninterrupted service, time the change around parts availability and the new team’s ability to take calls.
Decision Checklist for US Companies
Use one representative order to test the model from import clearance through payment and warranty service. Ask the commercial and finance teams to answer the same questions.
- Who must sign the customer contract, issue the invoice and collect payment?
- Which party can import the product and hold the relevant approvals?
- How much control do you need over stock, pricing, service and customer information?
- Who funds inventory, bears credit risk and absorbs the cost of returns?
- If sales expand, what contracts, approvals or staffing arrangements will you need to change?
Conclusion
Choose distribution when a local partner can reach the intended buyers, import the product and deliver the required service at a viable margin. Choose a subsidiary when direct contracts, local staff, or closer operational control justify the investment and the proposed activity fits Indian rules. Before committing, verify the assumption most likely to change the decision. That could be whether buyers will accept the distributor as seller, whether the subsidiary can serve the intended channel, or whether expected volumes can support the cash tied up in inventory and credit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a US company sell through an Indian distributor before forming a subsidiary?
Yes. A US company can usually sell to an independent Indian distributor that imports and resells goods on its own account. Before accepting the first order, confirm that the distributor can legally import the specific product and has the registrations and approvals needed to sell it through the intended channel.
Can a US parent wholly own an Indian subsidiary?
Yes, where the proposed activity allows full foreign ownership and the investment meets the applicable conditions. In particular, check the sectoral cap, entry route, and any conditions that apply to the investor or ownership chain. Also confirm how the incorporation will meet Indian membership and director requirements while preserving the proposed ownership structure.
Who acts as the importer of record under each model?
The distributor normally acts as importer in a buy-resell model, while the subsidiary usually imports when it buys goods from the US parent. Before dispatch, check that the purchase documents, shipping instructions and bill of entry identify the parties correctly and that the importer holds the required import code and approvals.
Does appointing an Indian distributor create a permanent establishment?
A distributor that buys and resells on its own account generally falls outside the dependent agent test. However, examine any additional activities the distributor performs for the US supplier and any local presence the supplier maintains. Review who secures orders, concludes contracts, and uses premises under the applicable rules.
How does a buy-resell distributor differ from a sales agent?
A buy-resell distributor purchases stock, sells it to customers in its own name, and earns a resale margin. A sales agent typically earns commission for soliciting or negotiating orders for the supplier. Before signing, confirm who takes title, who invoices customers, and whether the local party can bind the supplier.
What costs matter beyond the distributor’s margin?
Compare freight, duty, stock financing, local logistics, bad debts, returns, warranties and internal overhead. In addition, estimate when cash leaves the business and when customers pay. A model that looks cheaper per unit can still require more financing if it calls for larger stock orders or longer payment terms.
When do parent and subsidiary dealings raise transfer pricing questions?
Review transfer pricing when the US parent and Indian subsidiary enter into international transactions as associated enterprises. Goods purchases, trademark royalties and shared service fees can all qualify. For each arrangement, record how the parties price the transaction, what each party contributes, and which documentation and filings the relevant tax year requires.
Who handles product approvals, labelling and warranties?
The relevant product rules determine who must hold approvals and meet labelling duties. The contract can allocate practical work and warranty costs, subject to applicable legal obligations. For each product, check the named approval holder, the party responsible for label checks and the contact customers will use for repairs, replacements or complaints.
What should a US company check before granting exclusive distribution rights?
Check how the contract defines territory, channels, reserved accounts, targets and the right to terminate or narrow exclusivity. Then consider what happens if the distributor underserves a region or you need to sell directly to a national account. Review the proposed restrictions under Indian competition law before signing.
Can a US company switch to an Indian subsidiary later?
Yes, if the subsidiary can carry out the proposed activities and the distribution contract allows the transition. Before shifting orders, check notice periods, customer consents, unsold stock, and responsibility for open warranty claims. Also verify whether the subsidiary needs new approvals or changes to existing records before it can import.
